I'm back! Back in the midwest, and after many flight delays, finally got into O'Hare, and am curling up to the TV and the laptop around midnight... And I couldn't let anyone down... So it's American Idol time. You know the rules, I spout these thoughts off before the judges do their thing...
Lisa: Almost wow. It's a good pick, but I don't think you can almost hit the note in a Kelly Clarkson song. And tell the Joker that someone stole his eyeshadow...
Kelley: County when country wasn't cool? She kind of has to step it up a notch if she wants to compete with the top four in the competition. Again, gotta love her genuinely apologizing to these people.
Ace: Pulling out the Train, but man, if you're going to do Train, do Angels or When I look to the Sky - not this boring number. I'm not sure, but I think he actually looked less sexy tonight. And if he thinks that this is rock edge, then apparently he hasn't been watching Chris shred songs.
Taylor: And now another song you've never heard... I guess he made the song his own, I mean, how would anyone know otherwise?
Mandisa: Shackles, I wanted to jump up and do the rap - right Shelley? Needed to pick up the tempo a little bit, but man. Very good, but not the best version of Shackles I've heard. (CCC in the hizzouse) At least Randy will say something like "Finally!" and stop draggin the whole show down. ...Well, I guess not.
Chris: What if! He forgot to do his drunk swagger. Again, really good, but we know already. He's awesome. How many more weeks need to prove it?
Katharine: I don't like her hair straight. Where did the Prell girl go? I liked it, because I like her, but it's not great. Maybe it's because I can't stand Christine Aguilaeraoffdaa
Bucky: Before he even starts, he has got to go. Doesn't he know I'm watching this very late at night and I need to stay awake?
Paris: Work it out? Work out the I Dream of Jeannie hair and the Salt n Pepa garb. Still, her voice can totally kick tail. I think I'd like to hear her sing "What if"...
Elliot: Did he go up on those lyrics? It's impossible to know with all of those lyrics. This was a big mistake, as the lack of any interesting music will point people to his even less interesting face. I think he's a gonner.
Other random thoughts:
The judges are proving my theory on these weeks. They are almost useless, last week showed so clearly that there were four people who deserved to be in the top four, and all others should have been just let go that night. Because the A-players can't maintain the excellence for so long, particularly in song selection. I think the judges should get a cut in the middle of the season of voting, a chance for each of them, if they wish to, to nuke someone altogether, provided that they had been in the bottom three at least once. I think that would be AWESOME, because for twelve weeks in a row, plus the whittling down from 24 to 12, they have absolutely no power. They need some.
Taylor is oblivious to the fake hair of the deputy of soul patrol - what am I even writing? Paula and Ace's scar - I mean, come on. And Simon calling Taylor's look a little "pop school" as though that ISN'T what this whole thing is in the first place? Paula is retarded calling it the church of Mandisa. Creed would be seen drunk on this show, however - and Paula would show them where the happy flask is hidden... I think all night Paula has been trying to name drop on pop culture to pretend that she is still relevant. Does anyone actually need to hear the name "pussycat dolls" said outloud in any context?