Okay, each of the final four are performing 2 songs each - so I'll be as brief as I can...
First of all - Barry Gibb has done something to his face that has kept his mouth from working. Wow.
Melinda: #1 - Inside and Out - She turns this song into a Dionne Warwick or Gladys Knight song, very good, but she needs a second song that is more familiar to make an impression this week. #2 - How Can You Mend A Broken Heart - How can you make us care? She's exact, yes, but Simon is right -she's become the backup singer. Will the last long note impress anyone? Maybe.
Blake: #1 - You Should Be Dancin' - Flock of Seagulls called and they want their hair back. I can't hear his voice standing out in the falsetto at all, especially when the bgvs kick in - kind of disappointing to be honest. #2 - This is Where I Came In - A song from 2001. Much better than his falsetto, but ultimately the song was not memorable enough.
Lakisha - #1 - Stayin' Alive - Hot. Great musical arrangement, but this is probably the seventh time that AI has shown specific notes given to LaKisha from the guest and she has totally blown them off. Not that anyone could understand what Barry Gibb said anyway. #2 - Run To Me - She's more calm and not pushing, but it's not exactly interesting yet. Can she hit the high notes and the key change without screaming? Yes she can - It was great! Except for that horrific last note. Ouch.
Jordin: #1 - To Love Somebody - High Praise from the Plastic Gibb - She needs to win this thing. She has the most effortless powerful voice - the closest thing to the original Idol (Clarkson) in six seasons. #2 - Woman in Love - Great pick! She looks beautiful - still seventeen, right? Great key change! I think she's a no brainer to be head to head with Melinda for the finals - but can her young charm overpower the precision of Melinda? Hard to say, but tonight has made for her a career to last way past the show.
Say goodbye LaKisha... Blake will survive I'm afraid...