Here are my thoughts. Taking a little bit more time now that we're in the top 12 - so hold onto your wigs, THIS, is American Idol!
Yay a new set. Huh?
Yay Lennon and McCartney!
Syesha Mercado: Got To Get You Into My Life: Doing basically an Earth Wind and Fire version. Rough start, and I don't like her hair like that. How do you do an arrangement of this song with horns and NOT do the horn riff at least slightly as originally recorded? She has turned it into kind of a boring version. Lost the melody of it for me by singing too much "up" the melody line in a riff mode.
Chikezie: She's a Woman: Still hate the one name thing. He's no Cher. Props for the bluegrass tip. Boo for changing it and pretending that he's in the 80's band Living Colour. Should have stayed with the bluegrass. Obviously he can sing but it really seemed artificial to me.
Ramiele Mandalay: In My Life: The stairs just never work for me in this environment. It's like a gymnast move - like I get special points for walking and singing at the same time. The audience swaying their hands need to be disciplined. Could she take this song any slower? Could her lip gloss get glittery-er? Another one of those where it's a good voice, but doesn't have the heart, or guts, or something to really move me. Kinda milktoast.
Jason Castro: If I Fell: At this point, for some reason my tivo'd show on the HD channel thru Direct TV was losing sync between audio and video. So that was a bit distracting. (I don't know if that was universal or just me) Nonetheless, again, he's good but not with anything that is so earth shattering. He's just a cutie-pie that will get a lot of votes.
Carly Smithson: Come Together: These lyrics just never sound right to me unless John Lennon himself is spouting them. Hearing her correctly and Irishly enunciate "Ju Ju Eyeball" just doesn't work. For me. But she's the closest thing to heartfelt we've seen so far.
David Cook: Eleanor Rigby: His reverse iron-on comb-over is getting a little unruly. Emo Rigby via Nickelback. He means it more than anyone else, but I think he's still kind of a poser. But that was pretty good. But if I'm comparing him to Daughtry, he's not even close.
Brooke White: Let It Be: She's the one that I have started to like more and more every week, but I still can't remember her name. I just call her the Carly Simon-ish girl. More slings and arrows for the waving arms in the front, please... Good version, simple and clear, not her best, but I still like her a lot.
David Hernandez: I Saw Her Standing There: I saw HER standing there? Really? Changing the lyric to "the way she looked was FAR beyond compare" instead of WAY beyond compare totally missed the irony and the playfulness of the song. He just doesn't seem to mean it - wonder why. For some reason too, it kind of creeps me out that she was just seventeen (you know what I mean?)... Let's go boooooring. I have more to say about the song than his performance.
Amanda Overmyer: You Can't Do That: Never admit that you don't know a Beatles song. Never. Lie if you have to. Great pick from the moment the riff started. Bad choice with the backing vocals arrangement. She's hot tonight. When she stays in her pocket, she can't be touched, and this to me is the biggest difference between her and David Cook's versions of Rock out. I totally believe her - I mean, who else on this stage can say that "her whole family rides." And she means motorcycles, not roller coasters. Loved it.
Michael Johns: Across the Universe: Great, heartfelt, but like Come Together, when he gets to the "ohm" chorus, it's weird when it's not Lennon singing it. But still, he kept it moving and drove the song when it needed it, and I liked the arrangement except for the last notes, which seemed like a "star search" ending to me.
Kristy Lee Cook: 8 Days a Week: This style definitely fits her better, and it's the best she can possibly be, but in the end she's like Kellie Pickler without the spunk, and that's not going to make the boys vote for her long enough to keep her in the competition, no matter how torn her jeans end up by the end.
David Archuletta: We Can Work It Out: I can't wait for Randy to say that he "worked it out" Arghghhgh More stairs!!! Oh no, he just went up! Looks like he's human after all. Wow, I've never seen such a high fall in one week. He's gonna get through because of the fan base, but man, he just completely fell apart. Remember when he was good? I'm trying to...
Them's my thoughts. I think Hernandez is going home to his job as a pizza guy. Right.